| Samuel Ashbaugh (1825 - 1900) |
|
| Narcissa Knowles (ca1825 - ) |
| John Allen Ashbaugh | Annie <unknown> |
| b. 26 Dec 1860, East Liverpool, Ohio occ. edu. rel. d. 18 Oct 1937, Pike Co., Ohio br. |
b. 1870/1871, Ohio occ. edu. rel. d. Dec br. |
| Charles R. Ashbaugh Retha M. Ashbaugh |